A small case with an unusually clear picture of the payment pattern.
What happened
Vietnam Beverage acquired a majority stake in several Vietnamese alcohol companies in late 2017. Those subsidiaries had legacy customers in or connected to North Korea. Between January 2016 and September 2018 they signed 26 contracts to sell beer and spirits to North Korea, with two North Korean firms and two third-party companies, in Singapore and the Seychelles. Senior managers approved the contracts, and OFAC says nearly all the paperwork referred to North Korea and to payment in US dollars.
The subsidiaries issued 47 invoices under those contracts. The 43 payments that followed, totalling about $1,141,547 between April 2016 and October 2018, came from 15 different third-party companies, seven in Hong Kong, four in China and four in Turkey, plus the two companies in Singapore and the Seychelles. All were paying on behalf of the North Korean buyers or unknown entities in North Korea, and all 43 transfers went through US correspondent banks or, in one case, a foreign branch of a US bank.
Neither the holding company nor the subsidiaries had a sanctions compliance programme. New management learned of the sales in December 2019, ended them, and told OFAC.
The penalty
Non-egregious and not voluntarily self-disclosed. The base was the sum of the schedule amounts, $1,720,000, and the settlement was half of that, $860,000. OFAC credited substantial cooperation, including information on similar violations, and remedial measures. See how penalties are decided.
What the record shows
- The documents named North Korea and the payments came from elsewhere. Payment by unrelated third parties in several countries is what separated the paperwork from the money.
- The dollar was the hook. The sales were in dollars, so each payment had to clear in the US.
See third-country bank accounts, correspondent banking abuse, and the Hong Kong and Türkiye pages.